LearningSense vs CircleUp: an honest comparison for co-op directors (2026)
· By the LearningSense team
LearningSense makes this page, so read it knowing that. Every CircleUp fact here comes from CircleUp's own website, checked November 12, 2026, and every LearningSense fact comes from our pricing page the same day. Prices change, so check both sites before you decide. Sources are listed at the bottom.
LearningSense vs CircleUp at a glance
| Compared | LearningSense | CircleUp |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Plan by family count, monthly or annual | Plan by family count, with a monthly or annual toggle |
| Plans | Free $0 (up to 10 families); Sprout $29/mo (up to 35); Grow $59/mo (up to 75); Thrive $99/mo (up to 200); Network for over 200 families or several programs: talk to us | Free $0 (up to 10 families); Starter $23/mo, $276/yr (up to 50); Pro $60/mo, $720/yr (up to 100); Enterprise $100/mo, $1,200/yr (up to 200); Enterprise Plus up to 400 families at $159/mo billed annually |
| Annual billing | Annual is 10 times monthly (2 months free): $290, $590 or $990 a year | Annual toggle marked "Save 20%" |
| Fee on online payments | 1.0% on Free, 0.7% on Sprout, 0.5% on Grow and Thrive, plus Stripe's fee, taken from the program's payout; families never pay a fee | A flat 0.5% CircleUp fee on every plan, plus Stripe's fee |
| Checks and cash | Mark paid; no platform fee | Recording cash or check: $0 |
| Waitlists | On every plan, including Free | Automated waitlists listed on Pro |
| Volunteer hours | Volunteer shifts with a signup link on Sprout and up; hours and buy-outs coming this winter | Shifts with time slots and an hours requirement, with buy-outs billed for any shortfall on every plan |
| Grades and report cards | Classroom on Grow and up: assignments, grading, report cards | Class grades and report cards on Starter |
| Forms and waivers | Custom forms and e-signed waivers coming this winter | Signed forms and waivers |
| Phone app | Works in any phone or computer browser; a phone app is planned | iPhone app on the App Store; Android "coming" |
| Program website | Free program website on every plan, with a request to join form | Drag-and-drop public website builder |
| Church Parents Day Out | Classes by age, and 2, 3 or 5 day options with a per-day child limit on Grow and up | Not mentioned on its homeschool pages |
What a co-op pays per year
Subscription only, on annual billing for both. The fee on online payments is separate and covered below.
| Active families | LearningSense (annual) | CircleUp (annual) |
|---|---|---|
| 8 | $0, Free (up to 10) | $0, Free (up to 10) |
| 25 | $290, Sprout (up to 35) | $276, Starter (up to 50) |
| 45 | $590, Grow (up to 75) | $276, Starter (up to 50) |
| 60 | $590, Grow (up to 75) | $720, Pro (up to 100) |
| 90 | $990, Thrive (up to 200) | $720, Pro (up to 100) |
| 150 | $990, Thrive (up to 200) | $1,200, Enterprise (up to 200) |
Add the payment fees
Both charge a fee on Stripe payments on top of Stripe's own processing fee. CircleUp's is 0.5% on every plan. Ours is 0.5% on Grow and Thrive, so from 36 families up the fee is the same and only the subscription differs. On Free and Sprout ours is higher: 1.0% and 0.7%. For example, a 25-family co-op collecting $12,000 a year online pays $84 in platform fees on Sprout and $60 on CircleUp Starter. Run the numbers with your own family count and online tuition. Our pricing page shows a worked fee example.
Where CircleUp wins
These are real strengths, all listed on CircleUp's own site as of November 12, 2026.
- Volunteer hours with a requirement and buy-outs billed for any shortfall, on every plan. Ours are coming this winter.
- An iPhone app today, with Android listed as coming. Ours is planned.
- Class grades and report cards from its Starter plan. Ours start on Grow.
- Signed forms and waivers. Ours are coming this winter.
- A lower subscription from 36 to 50 families: Starter covers up to 50 families for $276 a year.
- A flat 0.5% payment fee on every plan, including Free.
- Plans up to 400 families with Enterprise Plus.
Where LearningSense fits best
- Church Parents Day Out in the same app: classes by age, and 2, 3 or 5 day options with a per-day child limit on Grow and up.
- Waitlists, sibling discounts and fees per child or per family on every plan, including Free.
- A lower subscription from 51 to 75 families (Grow, $590 a year) and from 101 to 200 families (Thrive, $990 a year).
- Parents keep allergies, medications, emergency contacts and pickup details current, and choose what teachers see.
- Staff background check and CPR records with expiry alerts, and up to 5 co-directors, on every plan.
- Grow and up: monthly tuition with automatic invoices and autopay, finance reports and a QuickBooks-ready export, and registration waves.
What LearningSense doesn't do yet
Not live at LearningSense as of November 12, 2026. Our roadmap shows what's being built.
- Volunteer hours and buy-outs (coming this winter).
- Custom forms and e-signed waivers (coming this winter).
- Check-in and pickup, daily reports and ratios (coming soon).
- Texting and SMS, calendar sync and a custom domain: not offered today.
- Transcripts and student logins: not offered today. A student portal is coming soon.
- A phone app: planned.
Switching to LearningSense
Import a spreadsheet or your current tool's family export. You match the columns side by side and see a preview before anything is added, then invite every family in one step. There's no setup fee and no contract, and you do it yourself. Switching between semesters is easiest. See how switching works.
Frequently asked questions
Is LearningSense a CircleUp alternative?
Yes, for homeschool co-ops and church Parents Day Out programs that want card and bank payments where families never pay a fee, and waitlists on every plan. If you need volunteer hour buy-outs, signed waivers or an iPhone app today, CircleUp lists them.
Which costs less, LearningSense or CircleUp?
It depends on your size. Both are free up to 10 families. CircleUp's subscription is lower from 11 to 50 families and from 76 to 100; LearningSense's is lower from 51 to 75 and from 101 to 200. From 36 families up, both charge 0.5% on online payments.
Do families pay fees with LearningSense?
No. Families pay exactly what you charge, by bank or card. The platform fee and Stripe's fee come out of your payout.
Is there a free trial?
LearningSense gives you 14 days of Grow with no payment info needed, and the Free plan covers up to 10 families. CircleUp's Free plan also covers up to 10 families.
Sources
Want to see it with your own co-op? Start your free 14-day trial, no card needed, or see pricing. Also see all comparisons and 10 homeschool co-op software tools compared.
Ready to give your co-op a real backbone?
Start your free 14-day trialFree for up to 10 families. No payment info needed to start.
More comparisons
LearningSense vs Homeschool-Life
Pricing at 8 to 120 families, payments, trials, and where Homeschool-Life wins.
Read the comparisonLearningSense vs MyCoop
Flat monthly vs family-count pricing, payment fees, volunteer hours and waivers.
Read the comparisonThe best homeschool co-op software in 2026: 10 tools compared
Ten tools with prices from each vendor's own site and a best-for line for each.
Read the roundup